Harmful Website Design Practices: Time for a Change

In August 2023, the ICO and CMA released a joint statement highlighting the detrimental effects of certain website design practices on user autonomy and privacy.

These practices, often known as “dark patterns,” manipulate users into making choices that benefit businesses but harm user experience and trust. The ICO emphasises the need for transparent, user-centric design, particularly in cookie consent banners, to ensure users can make informed decisions about their data. Both agencies warn of potential enforcement actions against non-compliant organisations.

Website design holds significant sway over user behaviour, influencing not only how easily visitors navigate but also how they make critical decisions regarding their data. The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) and the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) have raised alarms about the increasing use of manipulative design tactics that compromise user control and privacy. In their joint position paper, the agencies call for an end to these harmful practices and stress the importance of designs that empower rather than exploit users.

Understanding Dark Patterns

Dark patterns are deceptive design elements that trick users into making decisions that may not align with their best interests. These can include confusing consent banners, misleading language, and manipulative layouts that nudge users towards certain choices.

Impact on Users

The consequences of dark patterns extend beyond mere inconvenience. They can lead to significant privacy breaches, reduced trust in digital platforms, and even mental health impacts. For instance, a poorly designed cookie consent banner might inadvertently expose users to unwanted tracking and targeted advertising.

Regulatory Stance

The ICO and CMA’s position is clear: web designers and organisations must prioritise user interests in their design choices. The agencies highlight several key recommendations:

  • Transparency: Consent mechanisms should be straightforward and unbiased.
  • User Control: Designs should facilitate informed decision-making without undue influence.
  • Compliance: Adherence to data protection, consumer, and competition laws is non-negotiable.

Best Practices for Ethical Design

To foster user trust and comply with regulations, web designers should:

  • Implement clear, honest consent banners.
  • Avoid language that pressures users into certain choices.
  • Design interfaces that are easy to navigate and understand.
  • Regularly test and refine designs to ensure they meet user needs and legal standards.

Future Enforcement

The ICO has indicated a willingness to pursue enforcement actions against organisations that continue to use harmful design practices. This could include penalties and mandated changes to non-compliant websites.

The call to end damaging website design practices is a crucial step towards a more ethical digital landscape. By adopting user-centric design principles, organisations can not only comply with regulatory requirements but also build lasting trust with their users. As the digital world evolves, so too must our approach to design, ensuring it serves the interests of users first and foremost.

“Good design is obvious. Great design is transparent.” – Joe Sparano

Join us in creating a better digital experience. Evaluate your website’s design today and make the necessary changes to protect and empower your users. For more insights, read the ICO-CMA position paper on harmful design practices.

more insights